# A nurse is caring for a patient who has been diagnosed with terminal cancer. The patient's family is requesting that the diagnosis not be disclosed to the patient, stating it is their cultural belief that such information would cause harm. The patient directly asks the nurse about their condition. What is the most appropriate nursing action?

> source: MyMerci (mymerci.kr)  
> url: https://mymerci.kr/pages/nclex_q.php?qn_id=543615  
> language: ko  
> subject: Critical Care

## 문제

A nurse is caring for a patient who has been diagnosed with terminal cancer. The patient's family is requesting that the diagnosis not be disclosed to the patient, stating it is their cultural belief that such information would cause harm. The patient directly asks the nurse about their condition. What is the most appropriate nursing action?

## 보기

1. Respect the family's cultural beliefs and redirect the patient's questions to the physician
2. Inform the family that their request cannot be honored due to hospital policy
3. Acknowledge the patient's right to know their diagnosis while exploring their desire for information **✔ 정답**
4. Provide general information about the condition without mentioning the terminal prognosis

**정답: 3**

## 해설

Acknowledging the patient's right to know while exploring their desire balances autonomy with cultural sensitivity. Other options either violate patient autonomy by withholding information, disregard family concerns abruptly, or provide incomplete disclosure.

## 심화 해설

Understanding the Ethical Dilemma

This scenario presents a classic ethical conflict between the principles of veracity (truth-telling) and respect for cultural values and family dynamics. The family's request, rooted in a desire to protect the patient from emotional harm, directly clashes with the patient's explicit request for information. The core task is to navigate this without immediately shutting down the family or violating the patient's autonomy.

Analysis of the Correct Answer (Option 3)

The most appropriate action is to acknowledge the patient's right to know their diagnosis while exploring their desire for information. This approach is a direct application of patient-centered communication and ethical practice. It does not mean immediately disclosing the diagnosis against the family's wishes, but rather, it prioritizes the patient as the primary decision-maker. By asking the patient, "What do you understand about your condition so far?" or "Some people want to know every detail, while others prefer not to. What kind of information would be most helpful to you right now?", the nurse can gauge the patient's true desire for information. This aligns with the concept of relational autonomy, which is prominent in many non-Western cultures [2]. Relational autonomy acknowledges that a person's decision-making is interwoven with their family relationships, but it does not erase the individual's right to decide. The nurse's role is to facilitate a process where the patient's voice is centered, potentially leading to a mediated conversation with the family, not to unilaterally override either party.

Why the Other Options are Incorrect

- Option 1: Respect the family's cultural beliefs and redirect the patient's questions to the physician. This action is ethically problematic because it colludes in deception and abandons the patient. While respecting cultural beliefs is crucial, a blanket policy of non-disclosure can cause significant psychological distress and erode trust between the patient and the healthcare team. Research indicates that families often struggle with the burden of secrecy and that non-disclosure can negatively impact a patient's psychological health and treatment experience [1]. Redirecting the question is an avoidance tactic that fails to meet the nurse's professional obligation to advocate for the patient.

- Option 2: Inform the family that their request cannot be honored due to hospital policy. This is an overly rigid and confrontational approach. While many Western healthcare systems operate on an individual autonomy model, a direct refusal disregards the family's deep-seated cultural values and their role in the patient's support system. In many cultural contexts, such as those described in China and Ghana, family-oriented informed consent is a common practice where families take a primary role in communication to protect the patient's emotional well-being [2]. A blunt policy-based refusal can fracture the therapeutic relationship with the family, who are essential partners in end-of-life care . The goal is to negotiate a path forward, not to declare a winner in a conflict of rights.

- Option 4: Provide general information about the condition without mentioning the terminal prognosis. This is a form of therapeutic privilege applied without the patient's consent, which is deceptive and paternalistic. It assumes the patient cannot handle the truth, a justification often used by families to take primary control over disclosure [1]. This approach directly violates the ethical principle of veracity. If the patient later discovers the truth, it can lead to a profound sense of betrayal and isolation, damaging the nurse-patient relationship and complicating future care. The nurse's duty is to assess the patient's desire for information, not to unilaterally decide what information they should receive.

Clinical Application and Communication Strategy

The nurse's immediate response should be a calm, non-judgmental acknowledgment of the patient's question. A therapeutic statement could be: "That's a very important question. I want to make sure I give you the information you're truly looking for. Can you tell me what your understanding of your illness is right now?" This technique, often used in serious illness conversations, allows the nurse to assess the patient's baseline knowledge and their readiness to receive more information. Simultaneously, the nurse must engage the family privately, using a non-confrontational approach that validates their concern: "I can see how much you care about protecting your loved one. My role is also to care for them, and that includes being honest when they ask direct questions. Can we talk about a way to support them together that respects both your love for them and their need for answers?" This strategy acknowledges the family's protective role, a key dynamic in family-oriented decision-making, while firmly anchoring care in the patient's expressed needs [2]. This approach transforms a potential conflict into a collaborative effort to support the patient through a family meeting, where information can be shared in a supported, sensitive manner .References (research sources)

- [1]Family Disclosure of a Cancer Diagnosis to Patients.Research articleHu C, Zhao H, Yan Y, Fang F, Chen C, Yu P, Wei J, Waidley E, Hegarty J, Zhu P. (2026) · DOI: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2026.9954

- [2]"Because this is my body": patients', families' and health professionals' perspectives on family-oriented informed consent in China.Research articleLi JR, Walker S, Nie JB. (2026) · DOI: 10.1186/s12910-026-01422-6

## 임상 시나리오

Navigating Requests to Withhold a DiagnosisBalancing patient autonomy with family cultural beliefs
When a family requests non-disclosure, the first step is not to agree or refuse, but to assess the patient's own preference for receiving information. This respects the patient as the primary decision-maker.

Use a therapeutic communication technique to gauge their desire for knowledge. Ask, "What do you understand about your illness so far?" or "Some people want to know every detail, while others prefer not to. What would be most helpful for you?"

CautionDo not lie or provide only vague information if the patient directly asks. This violates the ethical principle of veracity. Instead, explore the intent behind their question before disclosing.

## 핵심 개념

- **Veracity** — The ethical principle of truth-telling and honesty, which obligates healthcare providers to provide accurate information to patients.
- **Patient Autonomy** — The right of competent individuals to make informed decisions about their own medical care, including the right to accept or refuse information.
- **Relational Autonomy** — A concept that recognizes a person's decision-making is shaped by their relationships and social context, balancing individual rights with family involvement.

## 같은 주제 문제

- [A registered nurse discovers that a colleague has been diverting narcotic medications from…](https://mymerci.kr/pages/nclex_q.php?qn_id=543607)
- [A nurse is caring for a competent adult patient who is refusing a blood transfusion due to…](https://mymerci.kr/pages/nclex_q.php?qn_id=543608)
- [A nurse is caring for a 16-year-old patient who was brought to the emergency department by…](https://mymerci.kr/pages/nclex_q.php?qn_id=543609)
- [A registered nurse discovers that a colleague has been diverting controlled substances fro…](https://mymerci.kr/pages/nclex_q.php?qn_id=543610)
- [A nurse is caring for a 45-year-old Jehovah's Witness patient admitted with severe anemia …](https://mymerci.kr/pages/nclex_q.php?qn_id=543611)
- [A nurse is caring for a 16-year-old female patient during a routine clinic visit who reque…](https://mymerci.kr/pages/nclex_q.php?qn_id=543612)
- [A registered nurse discovers that a colleague has been diverting controlled substances fro…](https://mymerci.kr/pages/nclex_q.php?qn_id=543613)
- [A nurse is caring for a 16-year-old patient brought to the ED by friends after a suspected…](https://mymerci.kr/pages/nclex_q.php?qn_id=543614)

---

More free questions: [기출문제](https://mymerci.kr/)

_학습 참고용입니다. 실제 임상은 최신 지침과 소속 기관 프로토콜을 따르세요._