Quick answerAcute compartment syndrome; notify the orthopedic surgeon immediately and prepare to bivalve the cast; monitor pain with passive toe stretch and sensation in the first web space.
Why this is correctCompartment pressure rises inside the fascia long before it can stop arterial flow, so pulses and capillary refill stay normal while muscle and nerve become ischemic. Pain that opioids do not control and that spikes with passive stretch is the earliest sign, and tingling in the first web space shows deep peroneal nerve compromise in the anterior compartment. Releasing the cast lowers external pressure while the surgeon evaluates for fasciotomy.
Easy analogy or mental pictureThe compartment is a closed suitcase being overpacked: the zipper (fascia) will not stretch, so the soft items inside (nerves, muscle) get crushed before the handle (pulse) is affected.
Memory hookPulses are the LAST to go — trust Pain and Paresthesia first.
NCLEX decision rulePain out of proportion that worsens with passive stretch after casting is compartment syndrome until proven otherwise; relieve external constriction and notify the surgeon, and never wait for pulse loss.
Why the other choices are wrongExpected swelling improves with elevation and analgesia and does not cause stretch pain or paresthesia. DVT causes calf pain and swelling but not severe passive-stretch pain or nerve deficits within 6 hours, so heparin, calf circumference, and D-dimer track the wrong condition. Arterial occlusion causes a cold, pulseless foot, but pulses and warmth are preserved here. Elevating above the heart is common for edema, but it lowers arterial inflow to an ischemic compartment; the limb belongs at heart level. An extra opioid masks the key symptom and delays decompression. Pedal pulse strength is tempting but is a late sign.
References
1AAOS — Appropriate Use Criteria: Acute Compartment SyndromeClinical diagnosis of compartment syndrome and urgent decompression
2NCSBN 2026 NCLEX-RN Test PlanClient Needs category and clinical judgment framework