Management Theories and the Nurse Manager Role | MyMerci
제안하기
0 / 2000

Management Theories and the Nurse Manager Role

Unit 2 · Topic 8Management Theories and the Nurse Manager Role
1.Key Concepts
  • Management — the process of achieving organizational goals by coordinating people and resources through planning, organizing, staffing, directing, and controlling.
  • Nursing management — applying that process to nursing services so that clients receive safe, effective, and efficient care.
  • Leadership vs management — management is a formal, assigned role focused on systems, resources, and results; leadership is the ability to influence others toward goals and can come from any nurse. Good nurse managers need both.
  • Management process (functions) used in nursing management texts: planning → organizing → staffing → directing (leading) → controlling (evaluating).

Levels of nurse managers

LevelTypical positionFocus
Top (upper)Chief nurse / director of nursingVision, strategic plans, policies, nursing department budget
MiddleSupervisor, department managerLinks top and first-line; coordinates several units
First-lineHead nurse / nurse manager of a unit, charge nurseDaily operations, staff assignments, direct supervision of care

Katz's managerial skills

  • Technical — clinical and procedural know-how; most important at the first-line level
  • Human (interpersonal) — working with and through people; important at all levels
  • Conceptual — seeing the organization as a whole and thinking strategically; most important at the top level

Mintzberg's managerial roles

  • Interpersonal: figurehead, leader, liaison
  • Informational: monitor, disseminator, spokesperson
  • Decisional: entrepreneur, disturbance handler, resource allocator, negotiator
2.Principles & Frameworks

1. Classical (scientific and administrative) theories — focus on efficiency, structure, and rules

TheoristTheoryKey ideas
Frederick W. TaylorScientific managementTime-and-motion studies to find the "one best way"; standardized tasks and tools; scientific selection and training of workers; differential piece-rate pay for productivity; separation of planning (managers) from doing (workers)
Frank and Lillian GilbrethMotion studyRemove unnecessary movements to improve efficiency
Henri FayolAdministrative (management process) theoryFive management functions — planning, organizing, commanding, coordinating, controlling; 14 principles including division of work, authority and responsibility, discipline, unity of command, unity of direction, scalar chain, centralization, order, equity, stability of tenure, initiative, esprit de corps
Max WeberBureaucracyHierarchy of authority, written rules and procedures, division of labor, impersonal relationships, selection and promotion by competence, documentation; authority based on rational-legal grounds (position and rules)
Luther GulickPOSDCORBPlanning, Organizing, Staffing, Directing, Coordinating, Reporting, Budgeting

Limitation shared by classical theories: they treat workers as rational and economically motivated and neglect human and social needs.

2. Human relations and behavioral theories — focus on people

TheoristKey ideas
Elton Mayo — Hawthorne studiesProductivity rose when workers received attention and belonged to a cohesive group, regardless of lighting changes; informal groups, morale, and social relationships affect output (Hawthorne effect)
Douglas McGregor — Theory X and YX: people dislike work, avoid responsibility, need control and threats. Y: people find work natural, seek responsibility, are creative; managers use participation and self-direction
Chris Argyris — immaturity–maturityRigid organizations keep workers immature (passive, dependent); managers should foster maturity — activity, independence, long-term perspective, self-control
Rensis Likert — four systemsSystem 1 exploitative-authoritative; System 2 benevolent-authoritative; System 3 consultative; System 4 participative (most effective)

Motivation theories (Maslow, Herzberg, Vroom, Adams, Skinner) belong to this family and are covered in detail under Motivation and Empowerment.

3. Modern theories

  • Systems theory (von Bertalanffy) — the organization is an open system of interdependent parts that exchanges energy with the environment: input (staff, supplies, clients, information) → throughput (nursing process, care activities) → output (client outcomes, satisfaction) → feedback (quality data, complaints) that adjusts inputs. A nursing department sharing information with other departments is interacting with its environment.
  • Contingency (situational) theory — there is no one best way; the best structure or style depends on the situation (environment, technology, size, staff maturity, task structure).
  • Theory Z (William Ouchi) — blends Japanese and American practices: long-term employment, collective decision-making with individual responsibility, slow evaluation and promotion, informal implicit control with formal measures, concern for the whole person, and strong organizational culture.
  • Management by Objectives (MBO; Peter Drucker) — manager and staff jointly set specific, measurable objectives, the staff member works toward them with autonomy, progress is reviewed periodically, and performance is evaluated against the agreed objectives.
  • Total quality management / continuous quality improvement — the whole organization continuously improves processes using data, with a client focus.
3.Application in Practice
  • Standardized procedures and checklists (e.g., a single pressure injury prevention protocol for all nurses) apply scientific management — they reduce variation and error.
  • Clear chain of command and written policies apply bureaucratic principles and support accountability.
  • Staff meetings, recognition, and team spirit apply human relations findings.
  • Shared governance, unit councils, and participative scheduling apply Theory Y, Likert System 4, and Theory Z.
  • Looking at a quality problem through inputs, processes, outputs, and feedback applies systems theory (e.g., high infection rates traced to supply shortages and training gaps).
  • Choosing a directive style for an emergency but a participative style for planning a new program applies contingency theory.
  • MBO fits annual performance appraisal: nurse and manager agree on targets such as completing a CPD course or improving documentation audit scores.

The Filipino nurse manager

  • Philippine law sets minimum qualifications (RA 9173 Sec. 29): for supervisory or managerial positions — RN, at least 2 years in nursing service administration, BSN with at least 9 graduate units in management and administration, and APO membership; for chief nurse or director of nursing — additionally at least 5 years in a supervisory or managerial position and a master's degree major in nursing.
  • The scope of nursing practice includes coordination with the health team and administration of nursing services (Sec. 28).
4.Nurse's Role & Responsibilities

First-line nurse manager

  • Plan unit goals and staffing; organize assignments and care delivery
  • Direct, coach, and motivate staff; handle conflicts
  • Monitor quality and safety indicators; lead improvement projects
  • Manage unit resources and supplies within the budget
  • Communicate between staff and upper management
  • Ensure staff practice within scope, maintain licenses, and meet CPD requirements

Staff nurse

  • Manage own client assignment (time, priorities, delegation)
  • Participate in unit committees and quality work
  • Provide feedback that helps managers improve systems

Managing change (often tested with management theory)

  • Lewin: unfreezing → moving (changing) → refreezing
  • Reduce resistance through participation, education, communication, and support; coercion or punishment increases resistance
5.Legal & Ethical Considerations
  • Managers are accountable for safe staffing, competent assignment, and supervision; assigning a task to someone not qualified may expose both the manager and the staff member to liability.
  • Managers must verify valid PRC registration and PIC of nursing staff.
  • For government nurses, the Magna Carta of Public Health Workers (RA 7305) sets working hours, allowances, and due process; managers must apply it fairly.
  • Staff and client information handled by managers is protected by the Data Privacy Act (RA 10173).
  • Ethical management means fairness in scheduling, promotions, and discipline (justice), and honesty in reporting (veracity).
6.Case Examples

Case 1. A new unit manager writes detailed rules, a strict hierarchy, and requires written documentation for every decision.

Theory applied: Weber's bureaucracy. Risk: rigidity and low motivation if overused.

Case 2. A manager analyzes nurses' movements during medication rounds and reorganizes supplies to cut walking time.

Theory applied: Taylor's scientific management (time-and-motion study).

Case 3. A manager says, "My staff avoid work; I need to watch them closely and threaten sanctions."

Assumption: McGregor's Theory X. Better approach for professional nurses: Theory Y — involve staff, give responsibility, recognize achievement.

Case 4. A manager uses a directive style during a code but a participative style when planning next year's training program.

Theory applied: contingency theory — the best approach depends on the situation.

7.Common Pitfalls
  • Listing motivating as one of Fayol's five functions — his functions are planning, organizing, commanding, coordinating, controlling.
  • Attributing "one best way" to Fayol — it is Taylor.
  • Calling the Hawthorne studies proof that lighting affects productivity — the key finding was the effect of attention and social factors.
  • Thinking Theory Z emphasizes formal, explicit control — it emphasizes implicit, informal control and collective decisions.
  • Treating contingency theory as "anything goes" — it requires analyzing the situation.
  • Forgetting that human skills are needed at every management level.
8.High-Yield Points
  • Management functions: planning, organizing, staffing, directing, controlling
  • Katz: technical (first-line), human (all levels), conceptual (top)
  • Mintzberg roles: interpersonal, informational, decisional
  • Taylor: scientific management, time-and-motion, one best way, piece-rate pay
  • Fayol: POCCC functions and 14 principles (unity of command, scalar chain)
  • Weber: bureaucracy — hierarchy, rules, impersonality, rational-legal authority
  • Mayo: Hawthorne studies → human relations, informal groups
  • McGregor X/Y; Argyris maturity; Likert System 4 = participative
  • Systems: input → throughput → output → feedback; open system
  • Contingency: no one best way; Theory Z (Ouchi): long-term employment, collective decisions, holistic concern; MBO (Drucker): jointly set measurable objectives
  • RA 9173 Sec. 29: managers 2 years + 9 graduate units; chief nurse 5 years + master's in nursing

다음 이론을 계속 학습하려면 로그인하세요.

로그인하고 계속 학습
컨텐츠를 그만볼래?

필기노트, 하이라이터, 메모는 잘 쓰고 있어?

내보내줘
어떤 폴더에 저장할래?

컨텐츠 노트에는 총 0개의 폴더가 있어!

폴더 만들기
컨텐츠 만들기
만들기
신고했어요.

운영진이 검토할게요!

해당 유저를 차단했어요.

마이페이지에서 차단한 회원을 관리할 수 있어요.