Budgeting and US Health Care Payment Systems | MyMerci
제안하기
0 / 2000

Budgeting and US Health Care Payment Systems

Unit 2 · Topic 9Budgeting and US Health Care Payment Systems
1.Key Concepts

A budget is a financial plan that turns the organization's goals into expected revenues and expenses for a set period (usually a fiscal year). It is both a planning tool (deciding how resources will be used) and a controlling tool (comparing actual results with the plan).

Types of budgets

BudgetCoversNursing example
Operating budgetDay-to-day revenues and expenses for the year: salaries, supplies, utilities, small equipmentSyringes, dressings, linens, education costs
Personnel (labor) budgetUsually part of operating; salaries, benefits, overtime, orientation, and replacement for time off — the largest nursing expenseStaffing for a 30-bed unit
Capital budgetMajor purchases with a useful life over 1 year and a cost per item above the organization's set threshold; also renovations and buildingsBeds, cardiac monitors, infusion pumps, a new unit
Cash budgetTiming of money coming in and going outEnsuring payroll can be met each month

Types of costs

  • Fixed costs — do not change with volume in the short term (rent, depreciation, manager salary, equipment leases)
  • Variable costs — change with volume (supplies, medications, meals per client)
  • Step-fixed (semi-fixed) — fixed within a range, then jump (adding a nurse when census passes a threshold)
  • Direct costs — traced to a specific service (nursing staff on the unit)
  • Indirect (overhead) costs — shared across units (administration, housekeeping, information technology)
2.Principles & Frameworks

Budgeting approaches

ApproachDescriptionAdvantageDisadvantage
Incremental (historical)Last year's budget adjusted by a percentage (inflation, volume)Simple, fastPerpetuates inefficiency; does not question existing spending
Zero-basedEvery item justified from zero each cycleEliminates unnecessary spending; ties costs to prioritiesTime-consuming
Program (program-based)All costs of a specific program budgeted togetherShows the full cost of a program (e.g., a pressure injury prevention program)Shared costs hard to allocate
PerformanceLinked to outputs and quality targetsEmphasizes resultsMeasures can be hard to define
Fixed (static)Set for expected volume; does not changeEasy to monitorMisleading when volume changes
FlexibleAdjusts expected costs to actual volumeFair comparison when census changesMore complex

Budget process: gather data and forecast volume → set goals and priorities → prepare the budget → review and negotiate → approval → implement → monitor monthly with variance analysis → revise.

Staffing measures

  • Full-time equivalent (FTE) — 1.0 FTE = 40 hours/week = 2,080 hours/year; 0.9 FTE = 72 hours per 2 weeks
  • Productive hours — time spent working on the unit; nonproductive hours — paid time off, holidays, sick leave, education
  • Hours per patient day (HPPD) — nursing care hours divided by patient days

Worked example 1 — FTEs. A unit averages 25 clients per day with a target of 8 HPPD.

  • Daily care hours = 25 × 8 = 200 hours
  • Annual care hours = 200 × 365 = 73,000 hours
  • FTEs if all hours were productive = 73,000 ÷ 2,080 = 35.1 FTE
  • If 10% of paid hours are nonproductive, each FTE gives 2,080 × 0.9 = 1,872 productive hours → 73,000 ÷ 1,872 = 39.0 FTE must be budgeted

Worked example 2 — Variance. Supplies were budgeted at $10 per patient day for 5,000 patient days ($50,000). Actual: 5,500 patient days, $56,000 spent.

  • Total variance = $56,000 − $50,000 = $6,000 unfavorable
  • Flexible budget for actual volume = 5,500 × $10 = $55,000 → volume variance $5,000 (explained by more clients)
  • Remaining price/use variance = $1,000 unfavorable (actual $56,000 − flexible budget $55,000) — the manager investigates this part

Worked example 3 — Break-even. A new clinic has fixed costs of $120,000/year, receives $100 per visit, and has variable costs of $40 per visit.

  • Break-even volume = fixed costs ÷ (price − variable cost) = 120,000 ÷ 60 = 2,000 visits per year
3.Application in Practice

Who pays for US health care

PayerKey features
Medicare (federal, 1965)People 65 and older, some younger people with disabilities, end-stage kidney disease. Part A hospital inpatient, skilled nursing facility, hospice, some home health; Part B provider and outpatient services; Part C (Medicare Advantage) private plans that provide Part A and B benefits, now covering more than half of eligible beneficiaries; Part D outpatient prescription drugs
Medicaid (federal–state, 1965)Low-income people; rules vary by state. The Affordable Care Act (ACA, 2010) allowed states to expand eligibility to adults up to 138% of the federal poverty level; 41 states including DC have expanded. The 2025 federal budget reconciliation law requires expansion states to apply work/community engagement requirements (80 hours/month, with exemptions) to expansion adults aged 19–64 starting January 1, 2027; HHS may let states that show a good-faith effort delay until no later than December 31, 2028
CHIPChildren in families with incomes too high for Medicaid
Private insuranceMostly employer-sponsored; also ACA Marketplace plans with income-based subsidies
Other public programsVeterans Health Administration, TRICARE (military), Indian Health Service
Self-pay / uninsuredOut-of-pocket; hospitals still bound by EMTALA

ACA key provisions: health insurance Marketplaces, coverage of pre-existing conditions, dependent coverage to age 26, preventive services without cost sharing, Medicaid expansion option, and payment and delivery reforms.

Payment methods and their incentives

MethodHow payment worksIncentive / risk
Fee-for-service (FFS)Pays for each service; Medicare physician fees use relative value units (RBRVS) × a conversion factorRewards volume; risk of overuse and rising costs
Per diemFixed amount per dayEncourages longer stays
Prospective payment — DRGsMedicare pays hospitals a fixed amount per inpatient stay based on the Medicare Severity Diagnosis-Related Group (MS-DRG) under the Inpatient Prospective Payment System (IPPS, since 1983)Hospital keeps savings or absorbs losses → encourages efficiency and shorter stays; risk of early discharge — discharge planning becomes critical
Outpatient PPSHospital outpatient services grouped into Ambulatory Payment Classifications (APCs)Same logic for outpatient services
CapitationFixed amount per member per month regardless of services used (common in managed care)Encourages prevention and efficiency; risk of underuse
Bundled (episode) paymentOne payment for all services in an episode (e.g., a surgery and 30 days after); Medicare's mandatory TEAM model began in 2026Coordination across settings
Global budgetFixed annual budget for a hospital or systemCost control; used in limited US models (e.g., Maryland)
Value-based purchasingPayment adjusted for quality and outcomesRewards quality, penalizes poor performance

Medicare value-based programs for hospitals

  • Hospital Value-Based Purchasing (VBP): withholds 2% of base DRG payments and redistributes it as incentive payments based on quality, safety, efficiency, and patient experience (HCAHPS) scores
  • Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program (HRRP): reduces payments (up to 3%) for excess 30-day readmissions for selected conditions (e.g., heart failure, pneumonia, COPD, acute MI)
  • Hospital-Acquired Condition (HAC) Reduction Program: 1% payment reduction for hospitals in the worst-performing quartile (Total HAC Score above the 75th percentile)
  • Medicare does not pay the higher DRG rate for certain preventable conditions that were not present on admission (e.g., stage 3–4 pressure injuries, catheter-associated urinary tract infection, falls with injury) — accurate admission assessment and documentation matter
  • Accountable care organizations (ACOs) share savings when they meet quality and cost targets
4.Nurse's Role & Responsibilities
  • Understand the unit budget and how daily choices (supplies, overtime, length of stay) affect it
  • Manager: prepare the budget with staff input, justify requests with data, monitor monthly, explain variances, and take corrective action
  • Staff nurse: use supplies wisely, avoid waste, charge supplies accurately, and suggest cost-saving ideas that keep quality
  • Prevent hospital-acquired conditions and readmissions — this is both good care and financial survival
  • Document conditions present on admission accurately (e.g., existing pressure injuries)
  • Start discharge planning and teaching on admission, especially under DRG payment
  • Advocate for staffing based on client acuity, not budget alone
5.Legal & Ethical Considerations
  • Cost control must never compromise safety — the nurse's primary commitment remains the client (ANA Code Provision 2)
  • Billing and charting must be truthful; billing for services not provided is fraud under federal law (False Claims Act) and can lead to civil and criminal penalties and exclusion from Medicare
  • Justice concerns: payment incentives can lead to underuse (capitation) or overuse (FFS); nurses advocate for appropriate care
  • Staffing decisions must follow any state staffing laws and employment laws
6.Case Examples

Case 1. A manager plans next year's supply budget by adding 3% to last year's actual spending. Approach: incremental. If she required every line item to be justified from zero, it would be zero-based.

Case 2. Under DRG payment, a hospital receives the same payment for a client with pneumonia whether the stay is 4 days or 8 days. Nursing implication: early mobilization, infection prevention, and early discharge teaching reduce length of stay and complications.

Case 3. A unit needs ten new glucose meters costing $300 each and one new cardiac monitor costing $12,000, in a hospital whose capital threshold is $5,000 per item. Budget: the glucose meters are an operating expense (each item is below the threshold, even though the total is $3,000); the monitor is a capital expense. Why: capital thresholds usually apply to the cost of each item, not to the total of a group of low-cost items.

Case 4. A client admitted from a nursing home has a stage 3 pressure injury that is not documented on admission. Problem: it may be counted as hospital-acquired, affecting payment and quality scores. Correct action: thorough skin assessment and documentation on admission.

7.Common Pitfalls
  • Thinking DRGs pay per day or per service — DRGs pay a fixed amount per stay
  • Confusing capitation (per member per month) with fee-for-service (per service)
  • Classifying supplies as fixed costs — supplies are variable
  • Believing incremental budgeting eliminates waste — zero-based budgeting does
  • Forgetting nonproductive hours when calculating FTEs
  • Judging a unit over budget without adjusting for volume (use a flexible budget)
  • Thinking Medicare Part D covers hospital care — Part A covers inpatient hospital care; Part D covers outpatient drugs
8.High-Yield Points
  • Operating (annual daily expenses), personnel (largest), capital (items lasting over 1 year with a per-item cost above the threshold), cash budgets
  • Incremental = last year + %; zero-based = justify everything; program = all costs of one program; flexible = adjusts to volume
  • Fixed vs variable costs; direct vs indirect
  • 1.0 FTE = 2,080 hours/year; include nonproductive time
  • Variance = actual − budget; explain volume vs price/use
  • Medicare A (hospital), B (outpatient/provider), C (Advantage), D (drugs); Medicaid = federal–state, low income
  • FFS rewards volume; capitation risks underuse; DRGs pay per stay and reward efficiency
  • VBP 2% withhold; HRRP up to 3% for excess readmissions; HAC program 1% reduction
  • No extra Medicare payment for certain conditions not present on admission

다음 이론을 계속 학습하려면 로그인하세요.

로그인하고 계속 학습
컨텐츠를 그만볼래?

필기노트, 하이라이터, 메모는 잘 쓰고 있어?

내보내줘
어떤 폴더에 저장할래?

컨텐츠 노트에는 총 0개의 폴더가 있어!

폴더 만들기
컨텐츠 만들기
만들기
신고했어요.

운영진이 검토할게요!

해당 유저를 차단했어요.

마이페이지에서 차단한 회원을 관리할 수 있어요.